
Holy shit, this cd is the most amazing thing
I have ever heard. Ever. Go buy it, now.
There's really not a lot to say about "As
the Roots Undo" except how great it is.
If you're already a fan of CTTS, pick it
up. If you're not, pick it up anyway, it'll
blow you away. And if you don't believe
me, go download "Non-Objective Portrait
of Karma" and listen to it. And if you can
honestly say you don't like it, I don't
know what's wrong with you.
Brad / Interpunk.com

"Rejoice, rejoice a noble birth!"
are the first words spoken before a clamorous
avalanche of schizophrenic drums and guitars
surrounds the familiar pseudo-call and response
singing style of Circle takes the square.
As the roots undo seems fitting for a CD
that oscillates from tangled cacophonies
to deconstructed, naked melodies and sounds.
As the roots undo is a wonderfully abrasive
collection of lengthy ballads both complex
and direct.
The first two tracks sound like the Circle
we know; quick and sporadic but with a bit
more experimentation. Similarly the remake
of “In the nervous light of Sunday” is punchier
and more condensed that the original. This
release really gets going after the aforementioned
trip down memory lane with the beautiful
lull of “Interview at the ruins.” The atmospheric
song is a wave of bent and soft tones moving
over a constant sample of sifting stones.
The next track “Non-objective portrait of
karma” is an epic that crescendos from a
80s sci-fi sound to a potent cluttered rock
masterpiece lyrically and sonically. “Kill
the switch” is classic stop and go searing
indie intensity expanded into a poetic exercise
almost ten minutes long. The last track
“A crater to cough in” is another remarkable
track dominated by a beautiful refrain hummed
in the CD's opening seconds.
As the roots undo is a outstanding full
length that is a testimony to Circle takes
the square's fluidic but jarring musical
moments. There is a blossomed intensity
and wonder here that was in utero within
previous releases. Buy and adore.
Ben Woodard / punkhardcore.com

Nothing is more excellent than when a fairly
unknown semi decent band out of nowhere
transitions into a butterfly etched in silk
and razor wire. What does this all mean?
Let's jump back a few years, more in particular,
when Circle Takes The Square released their
original album, which strangely happened
to be a demo. The concept of releasing a
demo as your first piece of recorded music
is far beyond my intellectual prowess, but
grasp tightly to this far fetched reality,
for one of the best albums of 2003 is about
to be explained.
Soon after its release, the demo was remastered
and put out on CD format under a just created
label Hyperrealist. This album was definitely
screamo influenced, but went back to the
roots of this recently formed genre and
embraced being loud and hard. While embodying
this wretchedly raw sound, they were still
able to have parts of melody and beauty.
The dual of male and female vocals added
another unique link to the chain of sound.
In short, the foundation for a good band
was there, but the structure itself was
short of great.
Within a few songs this smashed every expectation
I had set from listening to their previous
effort. Although the lack of a hip hop song
was sorely missed, Trigga and Quick will
always be remembered. The epic level went
from near nil to that of fantasy pilgrims
or . I was also amazed by the fact that
they could create such a full sound with
only drums, guitar and bass, which reminded
me of Majority Rule. As The Roots Undo definitely
doesn't fit in one genre, a new one would
have to be created for it, post screamo
perhaps.
"Intro", the first track, lures you in with
a softly hummed melody which is soon ruptured
by the following track, "Same Shade As Concrete",
with a volley of words and sounds. This
song displays one of the best assets on
this album, which is the ability to subtly
drop into a near silent breakdown. Similar
to City Of Caterpillar, there begins a progress
build back into and beyond the volume and
ferocity of what was before. The seventh
and longest track, "Kill The Switch", comes
close to being a whole ten minutes long.
Any song that can hold your attention for
that long is an achievement, especially
for music this hard.
"As The Roots Undo" is just as epic lyrically
as the music. At times these written words
are similar to those of Saetia, but the
way they are crafted to tell a story creates
a nice diversion from the vivid imagery.
Lines like, "My genes didn't bless me with
the foresight of a sage, but I know how
this will end, in apologies and ink on the
page", add visuals to the already dynamic
filled sound. The lyrics are set up in a
way where you can just take them as they
are, and it will be great, or you can look
much deeper to find more meaning.
Double bass can ruin the sound of a band,
especially when there are tons of stupid
double kick fills. Circle Takes The Square
is able to use the double bass effectively
with no cheese and metal stomping, especially
in the sense of adding heaviness to certain
key epic parts. It's also interesting, because
nearly all the bands of this 'style' use
single bass.
The vocals go through a few different types
of deliveries, keeping the sound from sounding
too flat. Yes, there is screaming, but there
are also harmonizing singing parts, whispers,
and even singing that is reminiscent of
Bright Eyes.
Potential sleeper hit of 2003, but if it
keeps getting pushed back, best album yet
of 2004.
Rating: 9.5 / 10
Zed / Scene Point Blank

As I write this review, the actual release
of this record has been delayed and delayed
so I can't comment on the amazing layout
this will most likely have (if the ridiculously
cool layout just for the demo was any indication).
Anyways, I want to tell a tiny story. The
first time I heard this band was when an
old band of mine played with them at a house
in New Jersey. They went on right before
us, and I figured I'd give this touring
band with the silly name a shot. They proceeded
to make the most noise I'd ever heard come
out of three human beings. It was tight
but sloppy where it had to be, a perfect
mess and beautiful and completely, heartbreakingly
human. When they were done I felt like there
was a new standard our set had to live up
to. That's what this record is: a new standard
for this genre. It takes all the potential
their demo/EP had and carries it to its
fullest extent. They take "screamo" to an
entirely new level. This actually feels
like an ALBUM, and not just a collection
of songs. Each track blends seamlessly into
the next and creates a mood of tension and
urgency throughout the whole thing. They
don't have to play fast and heavy all the
time to make their message heard. The softer,
building parts have such intensity behind
them. My only complaint might be that the
softer instrumental parts go on for a bit
too long sometimes, but it's a very minor
fault I can deal with. Amazing music, extremely
well-written lyrics, and vocals that sound
like the throat they're coming from could
fall apart at any second makes for the most
exciting release from this label or genre
I've heard in a long time. I can't wait
to see where they go from here.
Joe Decarolis / Abinka

One of the weirdest hardcore bands I've
ran into lately is Circle Takes the Square.
I wouldn't go as far as to call them geniuses,
but they do have an edge I hadn't heard
before. Imagine multi-layered, multi-rhythmic,
frenzied hardcore with evil black metal
vocals, clean singing, spoken parts, weird
guitar tricks and noise parts. Or as an
analogy, think of Dillinger Escape Plan
doing black metal whilst on acid. _As the
Roots Undo_ is without doubt my favourite
noisecore album of the year, giving the
buyer good value for their money with songs
clocking around six to eight minutes (total
running time of 44 minutes) and excellent
off-beat artwork -- hopefully they'll include
the lyrics in the booklet. Instead of rambling
on about this album, I can only urge you
to go out and buy it as soon as it hits
the shelves -- unless you lack a sense of
humor and like your music to be linear.
If you want to be on the safe side, there's
an MP3 of the album on their website. 9.5
/ 10
Xander / Chronicles of Chaos
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4
|
|