
For those of you unfamiliar with the Robotic
Empire line-up, get out from under your
rock because they it’s the best hardcore
has to offer today. Featuring releases from
Pg99, The Red Chord, Daughters, Mannequin,
Pig Destroyer, The Now, you know Robotic
Empire is serious business. The debut full-length
from Circle Takes The Square is another
terrific release to add to their growing
list.
After a 55 second whistling intro, “Same
Shade as Concrete” opens As the Roots Undo
with a frantic battle cry, “Rejoice, rejoice
a noble birth!” The frantic drumming and
guitars kick in and the insanity ensues.
It has been a long, long time since I have
heard any band able to combine schizophrenic
chaos with melody as well as CTTS does.
One of the best things CTTS has going for
them is their ability to write long, ambitious
hardcore ballads that never get boring.
Each song combines frenzied chaotic bursts
with epic build ups, melodic runs and a
chorus of overlapping, painful vocals. When
I say a chorus, think something along the
lines of a torture chamber... and the man
with the whip is very angry. If you are
into growls or hardcore cackling this wont
be for you. This is straight up yelling,
screaming, hollering, yelping, and even
some clean vocals here and there. It’s amazing
that there is only three members in the
band. “Same Shade as Concrete” features
some of these “clean” vocals that sound
a little bit like Conner Oberst - if he
killed people instead of crying for them
- along with some awesome female backup
singing. “Non-Objective Portrait of Karma”
commences with an atmospheric guitar intro
of nearly four minutes before the ADD enhanced
drums blast away as the highly melodic guitars
strum their way to oblivion.
The production on this album is remarkable
considering the layers of vocals coupled
with all the muddled textures going on within
the songs. Everything has a distinct sound
and stays clear throughout. Don’t let the
clarity fool you, there is plenty of raw
sounds to let their intensity shine through.
Seriously though, if you are unfamiliar
with Robotic Empire you definitely need
to check them out. Release after release
they never disappoint; As the Roots Undo
is no exception. I’m already pumped to see
what CTTS can do in the future.
Nailed Shut

Forget The Used and the rest of the emo-lite
brigade - this twisting, scowling, blackhearted
slice of malevolence from Georgia's Circle
Takes The Square is what post-hardcore's
all about. An uncategorisable blend of the
swirling etherealness of Cave In, the poisoned
shrieking of Cradle Of Filth and The Mars
Volta's complete disregard for song structure,
'As The Roots Undo' is a breathtaking body
of work. On pure aggression CTTS are fantastic
- when you add in the chilling male/female
vocals and the haunting prchestral chords
(think Vangelis' 'Blade Runner' soundtrack)
they're nothing short of awe-inspiring.
BEST TRACKS: 'Interview At The Ruins', 'Crowquill'.
Rating: KKKK
Kerrang!

One of Robotic Empire's greatest acquirings
in a while, Savannah, Georgia's Circle Takes
The Square destroys all the boundaries and
all of the things you thought you knew about
music. It's a record that can take the breath
right from your chest and leave you not
knowing what to say. It's cacophonic, but
it's soothing. It's left but it's right.
There's no solid definition that could encapsulate
this record. As The Roots Undo is as dynamic
as it gets.
Rating: 5+
dieatzero.com

As an album reviewer, you get very little
time to actually sit and enjoy an album
because you want to. You always have to
move on to the next batch of CDs and even
if you thoroughly enjoy an album, it's often
soon washed away by the next group of reviews,
good or bad. Gone are the days of repeated
continual day long listens of say Left Hand
Path or A Black Moon Broods Over Lemuria
that I used to enjoy before I got into this
writing gig.
However, an album has come to my attention,
that has me forsaking all other albums due
for review, an album so compelling, innovative
and draining, that even forthcoming albums
by Finntroll and Dismember will be hard
pressed to push it out of my CD player,
despite their no doubt brilliance.
As the Roots Undo takes the current melodic
screamo/hardcore trend and turns it on its
head with a bitter dual female/male vocal
attack (both clean and spit forth venomously),
seething black metal blastbeats, indie rock
karma and dreamy interludes of brooding
introspection. The genre shattering end
result plays like Thursday and Shai Hulud
watching Karen Crisis and Candace Kucsulain
from Walls of Jericho violate each other
with obscene sex toys in a deviant torture
dungeon run by Darkthrone (or is that the
dream I had last night?). Either way their
scathing Uphill Battle -esque take on hardcore,
is both a barren and beautiful sonic diatribe
that alternates from shuddering raptures
of pain and anger to swathes of subconscious
reflection via acoustics and instrumental
interludes.
Where do I start? This is an album that
demands to be listened to from beginning
to end, As the Roots Undo just unfolds brilliance
at every turn. Each song is an exhaustive
listen as CTTS are capable of shifting from
beautiful harmonies to acidic hatred and
sobering introspection, normally all within
one song, making detailed listening an absolute
requirement. "Same Shade as Concrete", fits
more moods into its four minutes than a
PMS stricken female serial killer. Although
some may find CTTS's chaotic delivery off-putting,
I found each caustic scream and riff to
be ripe with undulating melodies that only
surface with focused listening, much like
Shai Hulud. But unlike Shai Hulud, the bitter
edge is neither uplifting or soaring, but
vehement and strained with psychosis. "In
the Nervous Light of Sunday", highlights
the unusual female/male vocal delivery as
Drew reaches almost Dani Filth like peaks,
and his female counterpart wails with indignant
feminine rage or soothes with angelic fury.
"Interview at the Ruins", both pummels and
caresses, before revealing CTTS's softer
side with a stunning piano laced, chanted
close out, that's thick with sadness, truly
moving without being overly whiny or emo.
The last three songs on the album though
are truly magnificent, with Neurosis like
ambience ebbs to start "Non Objective Point
of Karma", CTTS display their unpredictable
personality that explodes half way in with
a devastating black metal burst with a throbbing
bass line reminding me of Ulver's Nattens
Madrigal. As if a polar opposite of the
prior track, the nine minute "Kill the Switch"
starts in a suffocating fashion, before
introducing the now purely heavenly moments
of brooding quiet. The sublime closer "Crater
to Cough In" follows the same peaceful/turbulent
formula as "No Objective Point of Karma",
building to a peak of claustrophobic intensity
and emotion.
Lyrically CTTS, while certainly utilizing
the cryptic song titles of their metalcore
peers, are on Shai Hulud -ish levels of
their own lyrically: "Rejoice, A noble birth,
a prince is born, behold the birth of violence,
beasts of bird and feather cry for our concrete
rapture. And if we beg to be put down, unto
us the most inspired storm. A princess ravaged
by her Prince: behold the birth of sex and
distance. Two frail corpses where they,
his eyes were the first to stray" ("Same
Shade as Concrete"). And while conveying
these poetic sonnets, Drew's clean voice
gets a little too whiny here and there,
his (and her) screeches are poisonous and
spiteful, more than making up for the emo
edge that may put off some metal purists.
Production wise, rather than the lush resonant
earth tones of typical metal core, CTTS
sounds are stark and primitive, with the
pulsing controlled bass providing the girth
over the flimsy drums and raw guitar tone,
but when taken as part of the whole, the
unusually barren sound works to convey CTTS's
unique sound.
I normally try to be level headed in my
reviews, and try to refrain from gushing
too much over an album I wont be listening
to in 3 weeks, but in the case of CTTS,
I'm not hesitant to throw around words like
'classic' and 'masterpiece', each listen
is a experience in itself. My only concern
is the 'emo' tag that comes with the band
putting off metalheads cautious of the term
and its musical saturation. Fear not though
wary reader, any listener brave enough to
shed labeling and genres will appreciate
the sheer brilliance of this album.
Utterly amazing.
Erik Thomas / metalreview.com

In the words of my esteemed ex-colleague
Troy Steele: “I had a self imposed rule
when I started writing reviews: no perfect
scores.” To me, the perfect score has always
been the most sacred of sacreds, something
that you could never touch, not even with
a really long stick. If you call something
perfect, what if something comes along that’s
just a little bit better? For this reason,
I would always leave that perfect rating
alone, just in case. My odd paranoias notwithstanding,
I was recently confronted with a situation
which challenged my no-perfect-scores standard.
What if an album is better than a 9, what
choice does the leave me?! I reached for
the ten, but at the last second backed away,
I knew it wasn’t the time for it. Yet.
Now, I’m not the biggest fan of hardcore.
To me, the entire genre is like a big bowl
of Corn Flakes. Somewhat tasty and satisfying,
but not something I’d want to eat too much
of. Of course, even something as bland as
Corn Flakes can be spiced up, with bananas
and sugar and berries and such. Breaking
loose of the standard scream and thrash
method is Circle Takes the Square, with
their brilliant release, As the Roots Undo,
one of the most innovative and interesting
hardcore albums since The Shape of Punk
to Come.
This is the first release by the band, and
it is simply staggering. It’s hard to make
these kind of statements without coming
off sounding like a drooling fanboy, but
this album is spectacular times three. Each
piece fits perfectly into the mix, creating
ornate compositions which can be both smoothly
serene and brutally vicious.
As the Roots Undo opens with a single melody,
whistled repeatedly like a sound floating
over a long silent void. This melody is
the theme of the album, coming back time
after time, both in the vocal arrangements
and music. It is a lonely, sad sound, repeated
slowly and carefully. The albums closing
track “A Crater to Cough In”, begins with
this melody once again, as it creeps slowly
forward over a four minute intro, winding
up an endless spiral staircase with determined
tenacity. Then, out of nowhere, it breaks
free, growing to a ferocious volume and
speeding to a breakneck pace, whipped through
the air like a sheet of looseleaf in a tornado.
I’m not one for hyperbole, but this is the
musical equivalent of Jesus returning to
Earth and baking you a five layer chocolate
cake.
The album is an epic, with fast, tight transitions,
screamed vocals and cleanly sung interludes.
The juxtaposition between the male and female
lead vocals only adds to the madness they
are able to swirl up. Long, carefully built
up intros and breaks stretch out a feeling
of tension in between the frenzied barnstormers.
Also, there are scores of things which you
won’t be finding on your run of the mill
hardcore album, for one, the choral arrangement
on “Non-Objective Portrait of Karma”, which
comes out of nowhere and sounds absolutely
sublime.
As the Roots Undo, approaches perfection,
but it just doesn’t make it all the way
there. Who knows what could be released
in the next few weeks, or months, or years,
which might put this album to shame. Imagine
then, what would happen to my credibility
if I gave this album a perfect score. I’m
not taking that chance.
Jesse Cataldo / Cloak and Dagger

Close your eyes to experience their sterile
intro, but be prepared for the desperation
that follows... I know I describe some bands
as desperate, but that was until I got to
know Circle Takes The Square. This record
is one of the most intense and emotional
records I’ve ever heard and breaths desperation
and so much more. Because of the multiple
vocal attack, varying from singing, screaming
and talking by both a guy and a girl, everything
sounds so intense. Musically this isn’t
boring as well, punk, hardcore, screamo,
and more rocky elements are combined, but
that isn’t all. Number 6 is one of the best
songs I heard recently, after a long soundscape
intro the driven guitars and intense vocals
took my breath away. Curious? Check the
song here. This CD is as hard to get into,
as it is catchy. All vocal lines stick in
my head for days, but still I discover new
elements within their songs every time I
listen to the album. The funny thing is,
that the screams of the singer remind me
of the way Danni from Cradle Of Filth used
to sing on their earlier records, but still
it perfectly fits the multi-rhythmic sound
of Circle Takes The Square.
All in all this probably will be the best
album in 2004, if it isn’t because of the
music, it definitely is because of the artwork.
This looks great and the special digi-pack
design is brilliant!
Tjeerd / codex4.org

This shit is just straight manic! Well executed
Hardcore that feeds off everything from
Goth to Power-Metal to Grindcore is the
element here. It seems that every member
of the band [including a lady] shares in
the vocal duties, which while creating dynamic
madness, it keeps the band from having that
certain kind of identity that a lead vocalist
can bring to the table. Putting that aside,
CTTS kicks major ass from a musician/Hardcore
fans standpoint. This crew delivers the
goods from musicianship to originality to
production. Their song-writing could use
a little help, but hey, they're young! I
See big things for this band!
Jeff Thies / Chord

After being delayed for almost 6 months,
this has been on the top of my list for
purchasing once it did hit the streets.
Hearing many great things about them from
the internet and word of mouth it peaked
my interest and inspired me to mail order
their demo. Unfortunately it left something
to be desired but the most important ingredient
was present, passion.
Now this three piece from the East Coast
is ready to get your attention in a way
that will impress you. First off, this packaging
is absolutely exquisite and should warrant
a good review for that alone. Full color,
multiple folds and textures that make you
wonder how they even create a package like
this. Musically speaking, this runs over
you like a mack truck with blistering vocals,
frantic guitar parts and the heaviest recording
I have heard come out for a three piece.
Comparing this to many of the other “screamo”
bands on the market right now really won’t
do it justice but I will say this, this
is our generations hope at a revival. Adding
such elements as a female vocalist, electronic
samples and atmospheric parts that remind
me of Mogwai on a bad day, Circle Takes
The Square have created a early contender
for record of the year.
This is important on so many levels from
the way that they present themselves, to
the way they create their music but overall
it musically outshines a large portion of
what has been released over the past few
years. Words really can’t justify the validity
of this record.
Ray Harkins / punkrocks.net
Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|